A band of misfit cupcakes have discovered a terrible secret about their creator. Daily aliens visit the creator to take some of them away to lands unknown. It is up to these misfit cupcakes to convince all of their friends and family into escaping the bakery with them. Little do they know, there are some muffins among them who are up to no good, and will stop at nothing to keep them from escaping.

Muffins among us is a co-op adventure where players play as 7 unique characters with different stats and abilities. Each character will play as either a cupcake, or as a muffin disguised as a cupcake.

The Muffins must not let their presence be known, as they thwart the escape attempts of the cupcakes. Or, they can choose to pose as a cupcake, and convince all of the other cupcakes to follow them to their demise.

All of the armies of the world have been defeated by the legendary monster Cthulhu. Civilization has crumbled beneath the chaos and destruction. Mankind is left defeated and without hope of any salvation. An unlikely group of rebels have come together to defeat the monster. They call themselves the Shepherds. Coming together in unity has not been easy for the Shepherds, as some of them only fight for personal glory and gain. However they are united through one common purpose: defeat Cthulhu, and save the future of mankind.

With all the world's armies defeated, salvation seems impossible. Until one day, a small peculiar stranger appears covered head to toe by a robe. He speaks in a low grizzly voice, muttering to himself as he limps towards them. What appears to be crumbs fall to the floor with every word he mumbles.

"I'm too late, they won't listen." he grumbles to himself. "Doom. Doom." The stranger hobbles closer to the Shepherds, more crumbs falling to the ground as he moves. "Hope, there is hope. You must listen. You must find them." The stranger grabs hold of the collar of a Shepherd pulling himself close.

"Find the Muffins."

The stranger collapses to the floor and seems to disappear as crumbs scatter across the room.